While sitting in a cycling chat room watching the US Pro
Championships this weekend, it was noticeable that there still exists
a strong animosity towards Tyler Hamilton. He seems to still be a
polarizing force within the cycling world—years after his alleged
doping. When he won the stars n’ bars on Sunday, many were cheering
him on. An equal number (if not more) groaned in protest. The latter
is unfortunate. He won the race by working hard and riding
strategically. Garmin easily outnumbered Rock, and with three
“Burrito Boys” finishing in the top four, Tyler had to use
insight, patience, and a well-timed sprint to take the victory in a
photo-finish.
So why is Tyler’s name still controversial? The thirty-seven year
old rider got his professional cycling start in 1995 with an early US
Postal Service. After serving as a lieutenant to Lance, Tyler became a
GC contender in his own right with Team CSC. Here, he met with great
success….and numerous injuries. Two of his biggest with the Danish
team were in fact with severe injuries—2nd place in the 2002 Giro
with a fractured shoulder and a stage win/4th overall in the 2003 Tour
with a cracked collarbone. Up to this point, many considered Hamilton
a hero.
The next year, Tyler rode for the now-defunct Phonak team, and this
marked the beginning of his fall from grace in the eyes of many in the
public. At the start of the year, Hamilton’s hemoglobin to red blood
cell count was high—but just beneath the suspendable amount. This
same test seemed to indicate the presence of someone else’s blood in
his bloodstream, but neither of these, at the time, warranted
suspension. Then, Hamilton won the gold medal at the Athens Olympics
in the TT. On September 20, 2004, it was announced that he failed a
test for blood doping. It wasn’t until June 27, 2006, that CAS
finally decided Hamilton got to keep his medal—but that was due
largely to the fact that his second sample, having been frozen by the
Athens lab, could not be tested. Many see this as a mere technicality.
The announcement on September 20, however, followed Hamilton’s
leaving the Vuelta just six days after winning the Stage 8 TT. He had
been notified by the UCI that his two samples from that victory were
suspicious. These four incidents were enough to be sentenced to a
two-year ban by the USADA in April, 2005. He appealed to CAS a month
later where his lawyers issued the now infamous Chimera defense. It
failed, and he was banned until September 22, 2006.
Just as his suspension was about to run out, on June 26, 2006,
Operacion Puerto reared its head. A Madrid newspaper claimed evidence
existed that Hamilton had paid for EPO from Dr. Fuentes. He vehemently
denied these allegations, but a few months later, newspapers in
Denmark and Belgium published details of Hamilton’s alleged doping.
In response, USA Cycling referred a new disciplinary case to USADA.
Meanwhile, Hamilton was hired by Tinkoff Credit Systems. The team
stood by him until La Gazzetta dello Sport reported that Hamilton was
one of the cyclists Spanish authorities named on Dr. Fuentes’ client
list. He was dropped from the Giro start list, and, according to his
website, Hamilton was asked to sign a new contract before he would be
permitted to ride again. He sued…and lost.
He rode as a free agent for the rest of the year, most-importantly in
the 2007 US Pro National Champs where he finished 6th in the TT and
12th in the RR. A few months later, Rock Racing signed Tyler. Though
the Tour of California did not permit him to ride, Rock used Tyler in
many races. In truth, Rock says he has more racing-days this year than
any other team member. His most important victory of the 2008 season
was the overall win in the Tour of Qinghai Lake—until today’s
victory in the National Championships.
With this history, it is understandable why some cycling fans are
skeptical. He seemed to be this great American hero. Then, all these
allegations started swirling, and many felt betrayed and confused.
It’s the “fool me once” mentality. This being said, with all the
racing he’s had this year, his tests have all come back clear.
Critics will read into this what they will. Some will feel the jersey
to be tainted. But, the fact is he served his time. What illegitimate
behaviors he may have done in the past are just that….in the past.
Tyler seems to be making an effort to come back strong and prove to
everyone that he is a great rider, capable of winning clean. Qinghai
Lake was the first major step in this quest…the National
Championships is the next. Some fans will never be swayed. Others have
stated that if he just admitted to past indiscretions they could move
on. But, for some fans, this year has been a pivotal watershed.
Without any brashness, Tyler has ridden his heart out on his bike.
This weekend was no exception. I have been to races this year where
fans have jeered for him. In response, Tyler’s just ridden harder,
letting his legs be his defence. That takes courage, and for that, he
deserves the respect appropriate to the US National Road Race
champion.
Jamie Naragon